• عربي
Fadel Abdulghany
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • BIO
  • Articles
  • Researches
  • Books
  • Quotes to the Media
  • Transitional Justice
  • Interviews
    • Talks and Lectures
    • Videos
  • Home
  • BIO
  • Articles
  • Researches
  • Books
  • Quotes to the Media
  • Transitional Justice
  • Interviews
    • Talks and Lectures
    • Videos
No Result
View All Result
Fadel Abdulghany
No Result
View All Result
Home Articles

The Right to Appeal: A Guarantee of Accountability, Not an Obstacle to It

19 November 2026
The Right to Appeal: A Guarantee of Accountability, Not an Obstacle to It

Fadel Abdulghany

On August 11, 2026, the Fourth Criminal Court in Damascus issued a death sentence against Atef Najib, and on August 18, it issued the same sentence against Wassim al-Assad; both cases are still pending before the Court of Cassation. Many have asked why the two sentences have not been carried out, and part of this debate has involved a confusion between distinct procedural stages.

The Code of Criminal Procedure grants the convicted person a period of 30 days to file an appeal in cassation, and the appeal suspends the execution of the judgment. The Code also obliges the Public Prosecution to refer every death sentence rendered in the presence of the defendant to the Court of Cassation, whether or not the convicted person has appealed it. Therefore, the expiry of the appeal period does not render the judgment final, nor does it render it enforceable.

The Constitutional Declaration issued in March 2025 enshrines the presumption of innocence until a final judgment is rendered. The passage of time alone does not amount to undue delay, as this depends on the complexity of the case, the conduct of the accused, and the manner in which the judicial authorities have handled it. However, the more important question does not concern these two cases alone; rather, it relates to the structure of criminal appeal in Syria in general: does Syrian law allow the Court of Cassation to review the evidence on which the conviction was based, or does it confine the oversight of the Court to the soundness of the application of the law and of procedure? This question carries a particular weight here, because the judgments of the Criminal Court are not subject to appeal, and so it follows that cassation is the only avenue of appeal available to the two convicted men.

What does effective judicial review require? Article 14(5) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), which has been binding on Syria since 1976, guarantees to everyone convicted of a crime the right to have his conviction and sentence reviewed by a higher tribunal according to law. The Human Rights Committee clarifies, in its General Comment No. 32, that the phrase “according to law” regulates the modalities by which this right is exercised and does not permit its denial, and that the right belongs to every convicted person, regardless of the seriousness of the offense.

In paragraph 48 of the same General Comment, the Committee requires a substantive review that covers both the sufficiency of the evidence and the correct application of the law; a review limited to the formal or legal aspects without an examination of the facts is not sufficient, as the Committee concluded in Gómez Vázquez v. Spain (2000). This does not mean a full retrial; rather, it means enabling the higher tribunal to examine the factual basis of the conviction to the extent necessary to verify its soundness.

As for Syrian law, Article 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure confines the grounds for an appeal in cassation to legal and procedural cases, among them a violation of the law or an error in its interpretation, nullity, and the absence, insufficiency, or ambiguity of the reasoning.

These grounds are legal in their essence; the general rule is that the Court of Cassation does not reassess the facts, nor the inner conviction of the trial judges regarding the evidence, even though the ground of deficient reasoning allows it a limited oversight over the logic of the judgment. Hence, what matters remains the actual practice: does the Court of Cassation examine the sufficiency of the evidence, including objections concerning the testimonies of witnesses and individual criminal responsibility, and is it able to quash a conviction that lacks a sufficient evidentiary basis?

Proving that serious crimes occurred is not sufficient to prove the contribution of a specific accused to them, or to determine the mode of his liability for them. The report of the Syrian Network for Human Rights (SNHR) on trial monitoring, issued on October 22, 2026, concluded that the case of Atef Najib relied to a large extent on the testimonies of witnesses, and that the case of Wassim al-Assad relied on testimonies, medical evidence, and information on armed groups, with the identities of some witnesses withheld.

The protection of witnesses does not, in itself, conflict with a fair trial; what matters, however, is that the defense retains an effective ability to challenge the testimonies and to test their credibility, and this is what the Court of Cassation should verify.

Article 49(2) of the Constitutional Declaration excludes war crimes, crimes against humanity, the crime of genocide, “and all crimes committed by the defunct regime” from the principle of the non-retroactivity of laws. As for Article 15 of the Covenant, it permits prosecution for acts that constituted crimes at the time of their commission under national or international law, or under the general principles of law recognized by the community of nations; however, it prohibits the creation of crimes retroactively, or the imposition of a penalty heavier than the one applicable at the time the act was committed. Therefore, the court still has to establish the legal basis of the crime, the mode of liability attributed to the accused, and the lawfulness of the penalty.

When the penalty is death, these requirements become more stringent. General Comment No. 36 restricts the death penalty to the most serious crimes involving intentional killing, and excludes it in cases of a limited degree of participation in the crime (para. 35); it considers the imposition of it arbitrary if the guarantees of a fair trial have been violated, including the right to an effective appeal (para. 41); and it does not permit carrying it out except pursuant to a final judgment, after access to all judicial appeal procedures has been provided (para. 46).

On the practical level, the defense should be given effective access to the reasoned judgment and to all the materials necessary to exercise the right of appeal, and the reasoned decisions of the Court of Cassation should be published after redacting whatever protection considerations require to be redacted. The legislator should also expand the scope of review in felony cases to include the sufficiency of the evidence, either by expanding the powers of the Court of Cassation or by establishing an appellate tier, and should enable convicted persons to submit requests for retrial based on new evidence directly to an independent judicial body, instead of the submission and referral of such requests remaining in the hands of the Minister of Justice, as is the case today.

None of this conflicts with the rights of victims to truth, accountability, and reparation; rather, it protects them, since these rights are built on judgments that rest on well-established evidence and a sound legal basis, not on the speed with which they are confirmed. The Syrian judiciary has today an opportunity to make these two cases a model of accountability in post-conflict transitions.

The mothers in Daraa who have waited fifteen years, and the families in Ghouta who lost their children, deserve a judgment that withstands every review, not a judgment that remains a matter of dispute for years. This will not be achieved except through serious work: a review that examines the evidence, published decisions that are accessible to the public, and a door open to every new piece of evidence. Only then does the right to appeal become what it ought to be: a guarantee of accountability, not an obstacle to it.

Source: Originally published on the Syrian newspaper Al-Thawra website (in Arabic)
ShareTweetShareSend

Related Posts

A Verdict with No Public Record
Articles

A Verdict with No Public Record

19 November 2026
The Great Plunder: What to Do with the Confiscated Millions of Assad?
Articles

The Great Plunder: What to Do with the Confiscated Millions of Assad?

17 November 2026
The Abolition of the Immunity of Administrative Decisions in Syria: Restoring the Judiciary between Authority and Right
Articles

The Abolition of the Immunity of Administrative Decisions in Syria: Restoring the Judiciary between Authority and Right

12 November 2026
Nationality Is a Right, Not a Grant to Be Requested
Articles

Nationality Is a Right, Not a Grant to Be Requested

9 November 2026
Independent Expertise and Parliamentary Oversight in Syria
Articles

Independent Expertise and Parliamentary Oversight in Syria

6 November 2026
Beyond the Judicial Rulings: The Role of INTERPOL in the Efforts of Syria to Achieve Criminal Accountability
Articles

Beyond the Judicial Rulings: The Role of INTERPOL in the Efforts of Syria to Achieve Criminal Accountability

27 October 2026
Tweets by Fadel
Fadel Abdul Ghany

Fadel Abdulghany

Founder and Head of the Syrian Network for Human Rights from June 2011 to date.

Master’s in International Law (LLM)/ De Montfort University/ Leicester, UK (March 2020).

Bachelorette in Civil Engineering /Projects Management / Damascus University.

Recent Posts

  • A Verdict with No Public Record
  • The Right to Appeal: A Guarantee of Accountability, Not an Obstacle to It
  • The Great Plunder: What to Do with the Confiscated Millions of Assad?

Quick links

  • Home
  • BIO
  • Articles
  • Researches
  • Books
  • Quotes to the Media
  • Transitional Justice
  • Interviews
    • Talks and Lectures
    • Videos

© 2023 SNHR - Fadel Abdul Ghany.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • BIO
  • Articles
  • Researches
  • Books
  • Quotes to the Media
  • Transitional Justice
  • Interviews
    • Talks and Lectures
    • Videos

© 2023 SNHR - Fadel Abdul Ghany.